Skip to content

The Evolution of Assuring the Public: A Chronicle of the Insurance Industry in Chicago

The insurance industry, a vital component of modern commerce, has a rich history deeply intertwined with the growth and development of major cities like Chicago. Chicago, with its bustling economy and diverse businesses, has played a significant role in shaping the insurance landscape throughout history. The Nelson Agency is pleased to present this comprehensive account of the insurance industry’s history in Chicago.

Early Beginnings

The roots of the insurance industry in Chicago can be traced back to the 19th century. The city, emerging as a prominent trading hub and industrial center, witnessed a surge in businesses and commerce. As trade flourished, so did the need for risk management mechanisms, giving rise to early forms of insurance.

Most notably, the Illinois Insurance Company, founded in 1839, was the first insurance outfit to operate out of Chicago. But the first insurance agent? That honor goes to fur trader, investor, speculator, and future legislator Gurdon Saltonstall Hubbard, who became the first registered Chicagoland agent in 1834.

Gurdon Saltonstall Hubbard

The Great Chicago Fire of 1871

One of the pivotal events in the insurance history of Chicago was the Great Chicago Fire of 1871. The devastation caused by this inferno led to a surge in insurance claims, bringing the insurance industry to the forefront of the city’s recovery efforts.

An illustration of the Great Chicago Fire in 1871

In the aftermath, insurance companies settled substantial claims, showcasing the industry’s crucial role in mitigating financial losses and aiding in rebuilding the city.

Lloyd’s Presence in Chicago

Lloyd’s of London, a renowned insurance marketplace, established its presence in Chicago in the late 19th century. This move was a testament to Chicago’s growing significance as an international financial hub. Lloyd’s played a vital role in providing insurance coverage for a range of risks, contributing to Chicago’s position as a global insurance center.

The Formation of Trade Associations

During the early 20th century, Chicago saw the establishment of various trade associations related to insurance. These associations played a crucial role in standardizing practices, sharing knowledge, and advocating for the interests of the insurance industry. Notable associations like the Independent Insurance Agents of Illinois (IIA of IL) were founded during this period.

Expansion of Insurance Offerings and Progressive Practices

Throughout the 20th century, Chicago’s insurance industry expanded its offerings to cater to the growing needs of diverse businesses. Life insurance, property and casualty insurance, health insurance, and various specialized insurance products became prevalent in the market. The city became a hub for insurance companies, brokers, and agents, offering a wide array of insurance solutions to businesses and individuals.

But it also made early strides in terms of both racial and gender equality. Supreme Life Insurance Agency, specifically, billed itself as “liberal” for this reason. Famously, when the inimitable Jackie Robinson needed to insure the slew of minority-owned businesses he’d helped to establish, Supreme Life stepped up to the plate.

Jackie Robinson signs historical business insurance policies in Chicago

This perspective on business pertained to its hiring practices as well. During the 1930s, their auditing and statistical offices were largely staffed by women of color. This was huge for the era – particularly when it came to mathematics-oriented business operations.

Supreme Liberty Life Insurance Co. statistical division in the Chicago insurance home office

Though the insurance world (and world in general) would still have a long way to go in terms of equality in the years to come, the Chicago insurance industry was unafraid to make some bold if unpopular choices because they were the right ones to make.

Technological Advancements and Digitalization

With the advent of the digital age in the late 20th and early 21st centuries, the insurance industry in Chicago embraced technological advancements. Digital platforms and online services revolutionized insurance processes, making it easier for consumers to access information and purchase policies. Insurtech, a blend of insurance and technology, emerged as a significant disruptor, streamlining operations and improving customer experiences.

Regulatory Changes and Compliance

Over the years, the insurance industry in Chicago and the U.S. at large has witnessed significant regulatory changes. Government bodies, such as the Illinois Department of Insurance, play a crucial role in overseeing insurance operations.

Illinois Department of Insurance logo

They are tasked with ensuring compliance with Illinois insurance laws and protecting the rights of consumers. The regulatory landscape has evolved to keep pace with industry developments and advancements.

The Present Landscape

Today, the insurance industry in Chicago is a vibrant and diverse landscape. The city hosts a multitude of insurance companies, agencies, brokers, and professionals catering to various insurance needs. The industry continues to evolve, embracing innovation, data analytics, and emerging technologies to enhance risk assessment, underwriting, and customer engagement.

The insurance industry in Chicago has come a long way since its early beginnings in the 19th century. From the aftermath of the Great Chicago Fire to becoming a global insurance center, the industry has evolved and adapted to the changing times.

The Nelson Agency stands as a testament to Chicago’s rich insurance legacy. We are dedicated to providing comprehensive insurance solutions tailored to the unique needs of the Chicagoland community. Our commitment to excellence and client satisfaction is deeply rooted in Chicago’s insurance history, and we strive to uphold the values and principles that have shaped this industry over the years.